The short version: Pricing conversations go wrong in two ways: the agent delivers hard news before listening and loses the seller, or tells the seller what they hope to hear and the home sits. The fix is to ask before telling, let comparable sales and market feedback deliver the news, and agree before listing on what to review, and when, if the market doesn’t respond. The post lists questions to ask, three starter resources (a Ninja Selling podcast episode on seller risk, Tom Ferry’s “Don’t Fire Me” report episode, and The Full Fee Agent), plus books, videos, and podcasts, and a checklist for homeowners.
When the market shifts, the hardest part of an agent’s job is usually one conversation: price. And it’s just as hard for the homeowner on the other side of the table, who’s watching their biggest asset and their next chapter ride on one number.
I put this list together for our agents, and I’m sharing it publicly on purpose. If you’re an agent, it’ll help you have these conversations with more skill and more care. If you’re a homeowner, it’s a look at what a good pricing conversation should feel like, and the questions a good agent should be asking you.
The Two Ways a Pricing Conversation Goes Wrong
Way 1: the agent tells the hard truth too fast. The seller feels dismissed, gets defensive, and hires someone else. Nobody listened to what the seller actually needed.
Way 2: the agent says what the seller hopes to hear. The home goes on the market too high, sits, and loses momentum. Months later the listing expires, a new agent lowers the price, and the seller has lost time, often money, and a lot of trust in the process.
The fix for both is the same skill, in three parts:
- Ask before you tell. Understand what’s driving the seller: a price, a date, a next home, or all three.
- Let the data deliver the news. Comparable sales, active competition, and showing feedback are more convincing than any agent’s opinion.
- Agree on the “what if” plan before you start. Decide together, while everyone’s calm, what you’ll look at and when, if the market doesn’t respond.
Questions Worth Asking
Ask, then stop talking and let the seller answer. Homeowners: these are fair questions to expect from your agent.
Before You Talk About Price
- “What’s on the other side of this move for you? Is it a price, a date, or both?”
- “And what else?” Ask it twice. The real answer is often the second or third one.
- “Do I have your permission to be completely honest with you today?”
When You See the Number Differently
- “Which would bother you more: leaving money on the table, or still being on the market in March?”
- “When you say ‘priced well’ versus ‘priced to move,’ what’s the difference for you in practice?”
- “If we’re still on the market at 90 days, is that a success? What about 60?”
- “If you were a buyer shopping at this price, which other homes would you be comparing this one to?”
Before the Listing Goes Live
- “If the market tells us something different in 21 days, how do you want me to bring that to you?”
- “What should we see by then, in showings, feedback, or offers, to know the price is working?”
That last pair matters most. Agree on how you’ll check the price while everyone’s happy, not on day 85 when everyone’s frustrated.
Start Here: Three Picks
If you only have time for three things, make it these: about an hour of listening and one book.
- Navigating Seller Risk: A Modern Approach to Pricing Conversations
Most sellers who want a higher list price aren’t being stubborn. They’re afraid of leaving money on the table. This episode shows how to ask which risk worries them more, leaving money on the table or not selling at all, and how to agree up front on a timeframe and the numbers you’ll check if they want to test a higher price.
- Never Lose a Listing Again: The “Don’t Fire Me” Report
A simple, recurring email that keeps sellers up to date with showings, feedback, and market data, so a price conversation is never a surprise. Also available as a video.
- The Full Fee Agent
Former FBI negotiator Chris Voss’s “tactical empathy” applied to listing appointments and client conversations. The lesson that matters here: help people feel understood before you ask them to change their mind.
Books
Most of these have audiobooks, which are perfect for drive time.
- SHIFT: How Top Real Estate Agents Tackle Tough Times
Written for the last market shift. Its pricing chapters cover pricing ahead of a changing market so a listing stays in front of active buyers.
- Never Split the Difference
The source material for The Full Fee Agent: labeling emotions, asking “how” and “what” questions, and why a “no” can make people feel safe.
- Exactly What to Say for Real Estate Agents
Short, practical phrasing for the hardest conversations agents have.
- Ninja Selling
Stop selling, start solving, by asking better questions and listening. Pairs with the Ninja Selling episode above.
- The Coaching Habit
Not a real estate book, but the best short training on asking instead of telling. Its question “And what else?” keeps you listening one beat longer.
- The Book of YES
Scripts for common objections, including price. Use it as a phrase bank, not something to memorize.
Videos
- How To Tell A Seller Their Price Is Too High (Nicely)
Why the word “but” erases everything before it and turns a conversation into an argument, with a short role-play and a question that puts the seller in a buyer’s shoes.
- How to Handle Overpriced Sellers (Without Losing the Listing)
One question for sellers who are attached to a hoped-for price.
- Say Goodbye To Overpriced Listings With This Script
For a listing that’s already on the market and sitting: how to bring up price with confidence and care.
- Never Split the Difference for Real Estate (paid course)
An eight-lesson video course on tactical empathy with sellers and buyers, for anyone who finishes the book and wants more.
Podcasts
- The Price Reduction Script That Every Agent Should Master
Six options to bring a seller when a price change is on the table, and how to prepare them early with market feedback.
- How to Sell Listings Faster: Smarter Pricing & Data-Driven Adjustments
Selling faster without losing the seller’s trust, including three ways to set a price.
- 6 Essential Phrases to Guide Sellers to Success During the Pricing Conversation
Six phrases for the conversation most agents dread, from the same coach as the video above.
- Why Expert Negotiators Love to Hear “No” (episode 683)
A free introduction to Voss: questions that help people feel safe working with you.
- YES Talk 154: How to Overcome This Killer Pricing Objection
For a home that didn’t sell the first time: give the last agent credit for what went right, then be honest about what was missing, which is usually clear expectations.
- Things to Consider When Getting A Listing Sold
Pricing right on day one, and having the expectations conversation before the listing appointment.
For Homeowners: What a Good Pricing Conversation Looks Like
- Your agent asks about your goals and timeline before naming a number.
- You see the actual comparable sales and the homes you’ll be competing with, not just a price.
- You hear the honest range, even when it isn’t the number you hoped for.
- You agree up front on what you’ll review, and when, if showings or offers don’t come.
- You get regular updates, so nothing about the market surprises you.
If you’re wondering where Central Texas prices are headed, our look at when Austin prices get back to 2022 is a good place to start, and every listing option a Central Texas seller should hear covers your choices for bringing a home to market.
We have no affiliation with any of these authors, shows, or courses, and we don’t earn anything from these links. Links checked October 29, 2026.
Sources
- Navigating Seller Risk: A Modern Approach to Pricing Conversations, Ninja Selling Podcast
- Never Lose a Listing Again: The “Don’t Fire Me” Report, Tom Ferry Podcast Experience
- The Full Fee Agent, Chris Voss and Steve Shull
- SHIFT: How Top Real Estate Agents Tackle Tough Times, Gary Keller, Dave Jenks, and Jay Papasan
- Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss
- Exactly What to Say for Real Estate Agents, Phil M. Jones, Chris Smith, and Jimmy Mackin
- Ninja Selling, Larry Kendall
- The Coaching Habit, Michael Bungay Stanier
- The Book of YES, Kevin Ward
- How To Tell A Seller Their Price Is Too High (Nicely), Aaron Novello
- How to Handle Overpriced Sellers (Without Losing the Listing), Byron Lazine
- Say Goodbye To Overpriced Listings With This Script, Brendan Bartic
- Never Split the Difference for Real Estate (paid course), Chris Voss and The Black Swan Group
- The Price Reduction Script That Every Agent Should Master, REDX Podcast with Patrick Ferry
- How to Sell Listings Faster: Smarter Pricing & Data-Driven Adjustments, Tom Ferry Podcast Experience
- 6 Essential Phrases to Guide Sellers to Success During the Pricing Conversation, The Walkthrough with Aaron Novello
- Why Expert Negotiators Love to Hear “No” (episode 683), BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast with Chris Voss
- YES Talk 154: How to Overcome This Killer Pricing Objection, Kevin Ward
- Things to Consider When Getting A Listing Sold, Mike Ferry TV with Tony Smith
General information, not legal advice. TREC says I can’t practice law, and I like my license. Run your specific situation past your broker or a real estate attorney.
← All broker notes · Get The Debrief monthly → · Talk with us →